When the Day Comes by Gabrielle Meyer: Book Review
Have you ever picked up a book and just felt like it was meant for you? That’s exactly how I felt reading When the Day Comes by Gabrielle Meyer. From the very first chapter, I was completely drawn into this beautifully written, time-crossing historical novel. It had everything I love—rich history, an incredible concept, characters that felt real, and an emotional journey that had me reaching for tissues. Let’s dive into my thoughts on this unforgettable read!
Just a heads-up, friend: This post may include affiliate links. Read my disclaimer for more info. Thank you so much for supporting Kaitlyn’s Bookshelves and helping me share all the bookish content I love!
Synopsis
Libby has a rare and extraordinary gift—she lives in two different time periods, experiencing two separate lives. One in 1774 Colonial Williamsburg, on the brink of the American Revolution, and the other in 1914 Gilded Age New York, just as World War I looms. On her 21st birthday, she must make an impossible choice: which time will she remain in forever?
As she navigates love, duty, and faith, Libby faces heartbreak, tough decisions, and the realization that God has a plan for her, no matter which path she chooses.
My Thoughts/Review
A Fascinating Concept
Time-slip novels always intrigue me, but this one? Absolutely brilliant. The way Gabrielle Meyer wove together two timelines felt so seamless and immersive. I loved the tension of knowing Libby had to choose between her two lives. How do you even begin to decide something like that? It made for such a compelling read.
Rich Historical Detail
One of my favorite things about historical fiction is getting lost in the past, and Meyer absolutely delivered. The Revolutionary War setting in Williamsburg was so vivid, and I could practically hear the bustling streets and feel the weight of the impending war. Meanwhile, the 1914 New York scenes were just as captivating, full of opulence and change. The historical accuracy and attention to detail made both worlds feel alive.
We must take whatever joy can be found from each day and not borrow tomorrow’s sorrow.
Memorable Characters
Libby was such a well-developed character and I found myself rooting for her through every challenge. Her strength, faith, and resilience made her journey so impactful. The side characters were just as compelling, from her family and friends in both timelines to the love interests who added layers of emotion to the story.
An Emotional Journey
I cried. More than once. The story tugged at my heartstrings in the best way, and I was completely invested in Libby’s journey. The weight of her decision, the moments of love and loss, and the way faith played a role in her choices made for such an emotional read.
A Satisfying Ending
Without giving anything away, the ending was so well done. It wrapped up beautifully, leaving me both satisfied and eager to continue the series. I can’t wait to see where the next book takes us!
Freedom isn’t stagnant or guaranteed. It lives and breathes and must be defended constantly. Don’t take it for granted.
Title: When the Day Comes
Author: Gabrielle Meyer
Genre: Historical Fiction, Historical Romance, Christian Fiction
Series: Timeless Series (Book 1)
Published: May 3, 2022
Publisher: Bethany House
My Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
If you love historical fiction with a unique twist, emotional depth, and strong, faith-filled storytelling, When the Day Comes is a must-read. It’s the kind of book that lingers in your heart long after you’ve turned the last page. I’m so excited to continue the series and see where Gabrielle Meyer takes us next!
Have you read When the Day Comes? What did you think about the dual timelines and Libby’s journey? I’d love to hear your thoughts in the comments!
📚 P.S. If you want more cozy bookish content and recommendations, make sure to sign up for my newsletter! You’ll get exclusive updates, book lists, and all things cozy reading life.
