The Dreams We Knew by Rachel Scott McDaniel: Book Review
Rachel Scott McDaniel has a way of bringing the past to life with compelling characters, immersive settings, and gripping mysteries. The Dreams We Knew is no exception. This 1920s historical romance blends murder, intrigue, and a second-chance love story into a page-turning read. With a private investigator heroine, a devoted detective hero, and multiple mysteries to unravel, this book kept me hooked from start to finish. In this The Dreams We Knew book review, I’ll dive into why this novel has become one of my favorite reads of the year.
Just a heads-up, friend: This post may include affiliate links. Read my disclaimer for more info. Thank you so much for supporting Kaitlyn’s Bookshelves and helping me share all the bookish content I love!
Synopsis
Delvina Salvastano Kline has spent her life balancing two identities: the privileged world of high society and the shadow of her birth father’s crime empire. Determined to forge her own path, she becomes a private investigator, stepping away from the expectations of wealth and status. But when a rising fashion model is found dead, Delvina is thrust into a high-stakes murder case—one that forces her to partner with detective Kent Brisbane, the man she once loved and lost.
As they navigate glittering parties and dark alleyways, they uncover a web of secrets more dangerous than they imagined. But solving the mystery isn’t the only challenge—Kent knows a truth about Delvina’s past that could shatter everything she’s built. With danger closing in, will they be able to uncover the killer before it’s too late? And can their hearts find a second chance amidst the chaos?
My Thoughts/Review
This book completely swept me away! The Dreams We Knew is easily one of my favorite reads of the year so far. Rachel Scott McDaniel masterfully balances romance, mystery, and historical detail, making this a truly immersive experience. Here’s what I loved most:
The Historical Setting
The 1920s New York backdrop was richly detailed, from the glamorous high society parties to the city’s grittier underbelly. I even learned new things about the era that sent me down a research rabbit hole which is always a sign of great historical fiction!
The Second-Chance Romance
Delvina and Kent’s relationship was everything I wanted. It was swoony, heartfelt, and full of flirty banter. Kent is the perfect gentleman, completely devoted to Delvina, and willing to fight for their love.
I’ll give up anything to have you.
Multiple Mysteries
Not only was the murder investigation compelling, but the mysteries surrounding Delvina and Kent’s past kept me intrigued. Instead of one big reveal at the end, the story gave just enough pieces along the way to keep me guessing.
The Emotional Depth
While the book had plenty of suspense and romance, it also explored deeper themes of identity, redemption, and love overcoming obstacles. The emotional moments were just as gripping as the action-packed ones.
This heart no longer beats for me, but for you.
Title: The Dreams We Knew
Author: Rachel Scott McDaniel
Genre: Historical Romance/Mystery
Published: February 25, 2025
Publisher: Kregel Publications
My Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
With its thrilling mystery, swoon-worthy romance, and immersive 1920s setting, it is a book that will stay with me for a long time. Rachel Scott McDaniel delivers an unforgettable story filled with suspense, heart, and beautifully written historical detail. If you love historical mysteries with a strong romantic thread, this is a must-read!
Have you read The Dreams We Knew yet? Let me know in the comments!
Don’t forget to sign up for my newsletter so you never miss a book review or recommendation. Happy reading!
