The Amalfi Curse by Sarah Penner: Book Review

The Lost Apothecary was one of my favorite reads last year, so I was thrilled to get the chance to read an advanced reading copy of Sarah Penner’s latest novel, The Amalfi Curse. Penner masterfully weaves dual timelines, blending historical fiction with magical realism in a way that keeps readers enthralled from start to finish.

Just a heads-up, friend: This post may include affiliate links. Read my disclaimer for more info. Thank you so much for supporting Kaitlyn’s Bookshelves and helping me share all the bookish content I love!

Synopsis of The Amalfi Curse

Set against the enchanting backdrop of the Amalfi Coast, The Amalfi Curse unfolds through two intertwined narratives.

In 1821, Mari DeLuca leads a group of women practicing stregheria, a form of sea witchcraft, to protect their village of Positano. When external threats endanger her community and loved ones, Mari faces heart-wrenching decisions that test her loyalties.

In the present day, nautical archaeologist Haven Ambrose arrives in Positano to investigate mysterious shipwrecks and secretly search for a treasure her late father claimed to have found. As she delves deeper, Haven uncovers a centuries-old tale of magic, love, and sacrifice that mirrors her own journey.

My Thoughts

Sarah Penner delivers another captivating tale that seamlessly blends past and present. Her vivid descriptions transport readers to the sun-soaked cliffs of Positano, immersing them in a world where magic and reality coexist.

The dual timelines are expertly crafted, with each narrative enriching the other. Mari’s story is filled with tension and emotion, while Haven’s quest adds layers of intrigue and discovery. Penner’s portrayal of strong, complex female characters navigating challenges across centuries is both empowering and poignant.

The infusion of magical realism through stregheria adds a mystical element that enhances the story without overshadowing the historical context. The themes of love, duty, and the enduring power of legacy resonate deeply, making this novel a standout in its genre.

Highlights

Dual Timeline Execution: Seamlessly blends past and present, creating intrigue and emotional depth across centuries.
Atmospheric Setting: The Amalfi Coast is richly rendered with sensory detail and a touch of eerie beauty.
Mystical Elements: Infuses magical realism into historical fiction in a way that feels both grounded and enchanting.
Complex Heroines: Both timelines feature strong, flawed women grappling with legacy, identity, and hidden truths.
Thematic Intrigue: Explores themes of inherited curses, family secrets, and the power of personal choice.

The Amalfi Curse is a mesmerizing blend of history, magic, and emotion. Sarah Penner’s storytelling prowess shines, offering readers a journey that’s both enchanting and thought-provoking. Fans of The Lost Apothecary and newcomers alike will find themselves captivated by this tale of love, legacy, and the enduring bonds that connect us across time.

A special thank you to HTP Books for a copy of this book!

If you love getting lost in the past as much as I do, you’ll want to explore my other historical fiction favorites. Find more reviews here!

Want more bookish coziness in your life? Join my email list for exclusive book recs, seasonal favorites, and behind-the-scenes peeks into my reading life!